Sexual orientation :
So I asked Arely "Is that all you guys talked about ?"
"Well as I approached Melody to ask her if she was going to tell our parents, she asked me 'How does it feel to have sex with Saul's size?' Since I wasn't expecting that, I said 'Huh?'" said Arely.
I responded to Arely "So she didn't mentioned your parents anymore?"
"Well sort of. Melody went on talking about how sex has not been enjoyable after giving birth to her 3rd kid. That she barely has started thinking of maybe going to a adult store and buying a toy just to feel the size difference. But when she saw you today, she thought that she can see how it will feel to have sex with an actual guy instead of a toy. She thought that a one time deal will be enough to see what she's missing and maybe it can be our little secret. I don't know if she meant not telling my parents that she caught us having sex or you having sex with her. She could use it against us and you know she will."
Melody has had a history of catching in the act before. Once Arely and I were making out with her tits out, when she walked in on us. We set up a deal where we would be responsible of washing her SUV (Expedition) every time we washed our car at home or at the car wash. This lasted about 6 months. I think this is what gave Melody the confidence of asking for such a crazy request. She knew Arely and I were easy to convince.
I didn't know whether Melody was serious about telling her parents but, we didn't want to take the chance either. Arely's dad was in the process of being moved to New Mexico for a job and we knew that Arely would be taken there if she made any mistakes in school or with me. I know the decision I had coming up doesn't sound like a tough one but it was.
I was in love with my girlfriend and never even thought of having sex anyone else ever. Now I have to decide whether to have sex with Melody or risk losing my girl friend to her crazy catholic parents.
I asked Arely "Will you be ok if do decide to do this?"
"Well it is going to be weird, but I don't want to risk what will happen if my parents find out we are having sex." said Arely.
"Heck yeah, its going to be weird! This is not an easy choice. Do I have time to think about it?"
"I think so. She didn't give me a time frame." said Arely.
I began to think of actually doing this. We walked outside to join the rest of the party. For the rest of the day I began, for the first time, to really check out Melody. I had never looked at Arely sister's in that way before. Melody like I said had recently fixed herself up. She has a good set of tits, even though she hasn't really ever worn a shirt to show her cleavage. So the boobs were still a mystery. After getting her butt work done, I realized she had been wearing more yoga type of pants and today she was wearing that with long shirt so her ass looked good. Well actually, it looked really good. Almost like a Kim K shape to it, hips and bubble butt combo. She has an okay face and was short.
Arely on the other hand was tall, has a small/medium bust (34B), a big butt for her shape and a face to die for. With Melody I would be able to experience sex with a busty and big butt women. I was never a big fan of big boobs but I guess I could use this experience as learning experience too!
I began to wonder,
"Will Meldoy let me do anal with her?"
"Will Melody let me give her a facial?"
"Will Melody let me fuck her like they do in porn?"
"Will Melody do pussy to mouth?"
These were all things that Arely would not let me do. She couldn't handle anal even tough we had tried a couple of times. She can't stand seman even when I cum inside of her. When we have sex, we actually make love and get into it really slowly.
As you can tell, it wasn't taking much to convince me to complete the pending task. But then I started thinking whether this was a trap from Arely, or what if everything goes well and Melody wants more sex later. This could cause big problems but I still didn't want to lose Arely to New Mexico!!!
So by that evening, I pulled Arely aside to let her know of my decision.
"Hey after pondering this for the afternoon, I've decided to follow through with your sister's request. I don't want to risk the consequences of your parents finding out. I hope we can get this done quickly and make it easier to forget."
Arely responds, "Ok. I'll talk to my sister about your decision and let you know about the details."
As Arely walks toward Melody, it starts to hit me. It starts to sink in that I'm going to have sex with my girlfriend's sister. Is this going to go over good or bad? What am I getting into?