This question is for the guy's that have experienced both.
Which do you prefer, or to put it another way if you could only put you penis in one for the rest of your life and the woman was willing, which hole would you pick???
Why? do they feel much different?

 

Vaginal, without a doubt.

Anal is great, but the feeling isn't the same, and although it's very very nice it's not the same hot wet warm slippery niceness

Anal might just be nice because it's still considered a little naughty and taboo!

 

I was thinking those exact things, the Vagina is made for it and anal is naughty fun!!!

 

Far more women are aroused by vaginal penetration that anal so that's got to be a factor too, knowing i turn a woman on arouses me no end. I derive my pleasure from pleasuring on the whole.

 

That's why I said "the woman was willing"!!!
If it didn't matter to her which would you choose??

 

I couldn't choose. I enjoy both and cannot think of going the rest of my life without the other.

Vaginal sex feels amazing, is awesome for building and maintaining the physical and emotional connection in a relationship, and is a great way to make baby's. Anal is for the wild, heathenistic, taboo nights that sex is all about pleasure and escape.

 

V

Vaginal

 

Same answer as before

 

anal is overrated.

Well unless its a sexy guy or a hot girl doing it to me

 

I got to go with the pussy.

One done i dont want to start a fire in her ass. Two yes it feels good but its hard to explane i just like pussy more

 

pussy is a pussy :

 

Anal can be TOO good. Like, hard to go for more than a handful of seconds without cumming.

 

If had to choose it would be vaginal. Anal is great but it is because it is more taboo and naughty. Also, she tends to get more pleasure from vaginal (although she does orgasm from anal as well).

 

Well I think vaginal because what if she wanted to get pregnant? (with my kid). Plus the vagina is made for it of course and anal is just taboo. Though it is becoming less taboo now-a-days, more younger people are trying as a means to not get pregnant without using a condom or to keep her virginity.

 

yea

vag

 

I love anal but you don't have to worry about cleaning up after fucking a pussy. You can just roll over and go to sleep.

Besides I just wouldn't have the heart to stick my cock in a gal's mouth after fucking her in the ass. Her pussy is a different story.

 

Easy...Vagina. I love the feeling of a vagina wrapped tight around my member, wet and warm...Anal is too much work, my cock wont fit most of the time...

 

BOTH! If adding the mouth into the mix then you have achieved the holy trinity!

 

I am inclined to agree with 614

but the vagina is probably best if it isn't too loose. A tight arse, or a mouth that can vary the pressure and feeling probably are better then. My fondness for anal comes from being a recipient. The efect on the prostrate makes it great for the man who isn't afraid of a cock or dildo in his arse. Frankly, I don't know what a woman gets from it other than the psychological effect.